By S A Ishaqui
Hyderabad, July 29: The Andhra Pradesh High Court found fault with the Andhra Pradesh Industrial Infrastructure Corporation (APIIC) for delegating its power to collect property tax from the industries located in industrial estates surrounding the city to Industrial Areas Service Societies. The state government has entrusted the management and maintenance of civic services in industrial areas across the state through an order in 1994 to the APIIC.
The APIIC had also delegated its powers to approve building plans. They covered industrial and non-industrial houses in industrial estates and adjoining areas in areas of municipalities and corporation under Section 13 and 14 of the AP Urban Area (development) Act 1975. It was also entrusted with the task of collecting property tax and other taxes. However, the APIIC delegated its powers to collect property tax, maintain civic services and mobilisation of funds through donations to the Industrial Areas Service Societies.
D. Srinivasa Rao, general secretary of APIIC Workers and Employees’ Union filed a writ petition in 1998, challenging the action of the APIIC. A division bench comprising Justice T. Meena Kumari and Justice Ramesh Ranganathan took up the final hearing on the petition. The bench in its recent observation pulled up the APIIC on how it could delegate its powers to others without any statute.
The court observed that the corporation has no power to transfer its statutory functions to a third party.
The court asked the counsel for APIIC whether they would out source the statuary powers vested with them.
It asked the counsel to inform it within two weeks whether the corporation would withdraw the powers from the Industrial Areas Service Societies.
Welcome. The only blog which provides the latest legal news and topics in Andhra Pradesh, India. Please have a view and send your comments.
Thursday, July 31, 2008
Tuesday, July 29, 2008
South Central Railway seeks Gandhi land for its metro
By S A Ishaqui
Hyderabad, July 28: The South Central Railway on Monday submitted to the Andhra Pradesh High Court that it would develop a world class railway station on the old Gandhi Hospital premises in Secunderabad at a cost of Rs 2,500 crore.
It informed the court that a proposal to transfer of lands to the SCR from the state has been pending for several months. The additional solicitor-general, Mr M. Ravindran, told the court that the SCR had put forth a proposal to the government that if the old Gandhi hospital land was transferred to it, the SCR would transfer its properties between Tarnaka and Sangeet theatre free of cost for road widening.
A division bench comprising Chief Justice A.R. Dave and Justice R. Subhash Reddy asked the SCR and government counsels to settle the issue amicably through negotiations and inform the court by August 8 about further progress.
Mr Ravindran said that before the hearing commenced, they had a meeting in the chambers of Mr Satya Prasad,special government pleader, and discussed about various options to sort out the issue including transfer of old Gandhi Hospital land to the SCR or appoint an arbitrator to fix a reasonable value for the SCR properties, which are going to be acquired. He said the Greater Hyderabad Municipal Corporation offered Rs 7,000 per square yard as compensation, which was not accepted by the SCR. He submitted that the prevailing market value in the area is Rs 30, 000 per square yard.
Mr Pouluri Bhaskar, standing counsel for Railways appraised the court about development of Secunderabad railway station and also showed proposed draft plan to the court.
According to Mr Bhaskar, the Union ministry of railways identified Delhi, Patna and Secunderabad stations to be developed into world class stations and in the recent budget the railways also accorded financial sanction for it.
Hyderabad, July 28: The South Central Railway on Monday submitted to the Andhra Pradesh High Court that it would develop a world class railway station on the old Gandhi Hospital premises in Secunderabad at a cost of Rs 2,500 crore.
It informed the court that a proposal to transfer of lands to the SCR from the state has been pending for several months. The additional solicitor-general, Mr M. Ravindran, told the court that the SCR had put forth a proposal to the government that if the old Gandhi hospital land was transferred to it, the SCR would transfer its properties between Tarnaka and Sangeet theatre free of cost for road widening.
A division bench comprising Chief Justice A.R. Dave and Justice R. Subhash Reddy asked the SCR and government counsels to settle the issue amicably through negotiations and inform the court by August 8 about further progress.
Mr Ravindran said that before the hearing commenced, they had a meeting in the chambers of Mr Satya Prasad,special government pleader, and discussed about various options to sort out the issue including transfer of old Gandhi Hospital land to the SCR or appoint an arbitrator to fix a reasonable value for the SCR properties, which are going to be acquired. He said the Greater Hyderabad Municipal Corporation offered Rs 7,000 per square yard as compensation, which was not accepted by the SCR. He submitted that the prevailing market value in the area is Rs 30, 000 per square yard.
Mr Pouluri Bhaskar, standing counsel for Railways appraised the court about development of Secunderabad railway station and also showed proposed draft plan to the court.
According to Mr Bhaskar, the Union ministry of railways identified Delhi, Patna and Secunderabad stations to be developed into world class stations and in the recent budget the railways also accorded financial sanction for it.
Saturday, July 26, 2008
Hyderabad, July 23 : The AP High Court on Wednesday declared that selection of candidates for the Group 1 main examination in the ratio of 1: 50 in the order of merit without reference category or community was irrational.
Mr Baloji Badhavath and 31 others have challenged the orders of the APAdministrative Tribunal on publishing results of examinations conducted by the AP Public Service Commission.
The tribunal passed an order on July 4 upholding the clause of the GO Ms.No. 570, that the number of candidates admitted to the written examinations would be 50 times the total number of vacancies available at the time irrespective of communities.
A division bench comprising Justice Ghulam Mohammed and Justice C.V.Ramulu while allowing the petition observed that clause irrespective of communities in the GO is declared as irrational and the words 'irrespective ofcommunities' are set aside".
The court agreed with contention of senior advocate S Ramachnadra Rao who appeared on behalf of the petitioner.
He said that the APPSC had violated the right to equal opportunity guaranteed under Article 16 of the Constitution by excluding the reserve categories from the zone of consideration.
"After the court verdict the APPSC now has to undertake a fresh exercise to select candidates on basis of reservations including women and issue call letters to the candidates for Group-I main examinations" said MrRamachandra Rao.
The APPSC selected 9800 candidates to the main examination out of 1, 68,000 candidates who appeared in preliminary examinations.
Thursday, July 24, 2008
APPSC Group 1 exams: HC voids PSC order
By S A Ishaqui
Hyderabad, July 23 : The AP High Court on Wednesday declared that selection of candidates for the Group 1 main examination in the ratio of 1: 50 in the order of merit without reference category or community was irrational.
A division bench comprising Justice Ghulam Mohammed and Justice C.V. Ramulu while allowing the petition observed that clause irrespective of communities in the GO is declared as irrational and the words 'irrespective of communities' are set aside".
The court agreed with contention of senior advocate S Ramachnadra Rao who appeared on behalf of the petitioner.
He said that the APPSC has violated the right to equal opportunity guaranteed under Article 16 of the Constitution by excluding the reserve categories from the zone of consideration.
The High Court's decisin came after Mr Baloji Badhavath and 31 others challenged the orders of the AP Administrative Tribunal on publishing results of examinations conducted by the AP Public Service Commission.
The tribunal passed an order on July 4 upholding the clause of the GO Ms. No. 570, that the number of candidates admitted to the written examinations would be 50 times the total number of vacancies available at the time irrespective of communities.
"After the court verdict the APPSC now has to undertake a fresh exercise to select candidates on basis of reservations including women and issue call letters to the candidates once again for Group-I main examinations" said Mr Rao.
The APPSC selected 9800 candidates to the main examination out of 1, 68, 000 candidates who appeared in preliminary examinations.
Hyderabad, July 23 : The AP High Court on Wednesday declared that selection of candidates for the Group 1 main examination in the ratio of 1: 50 in the order of merit without reference category or community was irrational.
A division bench comprising Justice Ghulam Mohammed and Justice C.V. Ramulu while allowing the petition observed that clause irrespective of communities in the GO is declared as irrational and the words 'irrespective of communities' are set aside".
The court agreed with contention of senior advocate S Ramachnadra Rao who appeared on behalf of the petitioner.
He said that the APPSC has violated the right to equal opportunity guaranteed under Article 16 of the Constitution by excluding the reserve categories from the zone of consideration.
The High Court's decisin came after Mr Baloji Badhavath and 31 others challenged the orders of the AP Administrative Tribunal on publishing results of examinations conducted by the AP Public Service Commission.
The tribunal passed an order on July 4 upholding the clause of the GO Ms. No. 570, that the number of candidates admitted to the written examinations would be 50 times the total number of vacancies available at the time irrespective of communities.
"After the court verdict the APPSC now has to undertake a fresh exercise to select candidates on basis of reservations including women and issue call letters to the candidates once again for Group-I main examinations" said Mr Rao.
The APPSC selected 9800 candidates to the main examination out of 1, 68, 000 candidates who appeared in preliminary examinations.
Wednesday, July 23, 2008
Woman wins after eight years
By S A Ishaqui
Hyderabad, July 22: A woman has won an eight-year-old legal battle against Kadapa district collector over an erroneous order passed against her.
The Andhra Pradesh High Court has held that the district collector committed a grave error in invoking the provisions of Rule 9 of Andhra Pradesh (Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and Backward Classes) Regulation of Issue of Community Certificates Act 1993, in relation to the petitioner.
Justice CV Nagarjuna Reddy also imposed costs of Rs 10,000 on Kadapa collector and directed that he pay it to the petitioner,Ms KL Sulochanamma, resident of Thavvaripally village in Kadapa district.
Ms Sulochanamma applied for post of extra departmental branch post master at Thavvaripally village.
Another candidate who applied for the post unsuccessfully complained to the authorities that the petitioner was not resident of the village and alleged that she obtained a false community certificate claiming that she belongs to Scheduled Caste community.
The collector than issued a show cause notice to her and Ms Sulochanamma replied to it that she had not secured any community certificate.
After perusing the records relating to the issue, the court held that "the facts reveal that it is no one's case that the petitioner obtained a false certificate and secured job on the basis of it.It is further clear that with respect to the nativity certificate, even assuming that the same is false, the petitioner not secured employment on the strength of it".
The judge set aside the orders passed by the collector to initiate action against the petitioner for allegedly obtaining fake community certificate.
Justices Reddy said "the whole approach of the collector is perverse and vitiated by total non-application of mind and betrays lack of any comprehension on his part regarding the scope of the provisions of the Act and jurisdiction available for him to initiate action".
The court declared that the order was wholly without jurisdiction. The judge said that costs were imposed on the collector "for subjecting the petitioner to vexatious litigation, which would have caused her severe mental agony, apart from unnecessary expenditure in fighting the needless litigation".
If the collector did not pay the amount , the petitioner can recover the cost through legal process.
.
Hyderabad, July 22: A woman has won an eight-year-old legal battle against Kadapa district collector over an erroneous order passed against her.
The Andhra Pradesh High Court has held that the district collector committed a grave error in invoking the provisions of Rule 9 of Andhra Pradesh (Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and Backward Classes) Regulation of Issue of Community Certificates Act 1993, in relation to the petitioner.
Justice CV Nagarjuna Reddy also imposed costs of Rs 10,000 on Kadapa collector and directed that he pay it to the petitioner,Ms KL Sulochanamma, resident of Thavvaripally village in Kadapa district.
Ms Sulochanamma applied for post of extra departmental branch post master at Thavvaripally village.
Another candidate who applied for the post unsuccessfully complained to the authorities that the petitioner was not resident of the village and alleged that she obtained a false community certificate claiming that she belongs to Scheduled Caste community.
The collector than issued a show cause notice to her and Ms Sulochanamma replied to it that she had not secured any community certificate.
After perusing the records relating to the issue, the court held that "the facts reveal that it is no one's case that the petitioner obtained a false certificate and secured job on the basis of it.It is further clear that with respect to the nativity certificate, even assuming that the same is false, the petitioner not secured employment on the strength of it".
The judge set aside the orders passed by the collector to initiate action against the petitioner for allegedly obtaining fake community certificate.
Justices Reddy said "the whole approach of the collector is perverse and vitiated by total non-application of mind and betrays lack of any comprehension on his part regarding the scope of the provisions of the Act and jurisdiction available for him to initiate action".
The court declared that the order was wholly without jurisdiction. The judge said that costs were imposed on the collector "for subjecting the petitioner to vexatious litigation, which would have caused her severe mental agony, apart from unnecessary expenditure in fighting the needless litigation".
If the collector did not pay the amount , the petitioner can recover the cost through legal process.
.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)